10 WAYS AN EMPLOYER CAN DEAL WITH WRONGFUL TERMINATION.

1] Have the documents in place :- If the company has asked you to leave for performance related issues, see that you have adequate documentation required to deal with the allegations. Also any rewards and recognition handed to you in the recent past can be used as an evidence that your performance was upto the mark.

2] Build up credible evidence :- Any photographs of manhandling by employer or any audio recordings will be admissible as evidence only if you get it properly verified in an independent lab prior to presenting it in the court.

3] Read the employment contract carefully :- A contract usually provides for a notice period or pay in lieu of notice. Hence, a company can merely pay you and ask you to leave within hours. Read the contract to see if you are eligible for both notice and payment.

4] Approach the labour commissioner :- An employee can approach the labour commissioner in the region to represent their side of the story and a possible solution.

5] Keep employer in the loop :- Even if you plan to take an action against the employer, it is advisable to inform them through a formal mail about your decision.

6] Stay away from bad mouthing the company :- Whatever be your grouches against the employer, it is considered unprofessional to bad mouth the company on a public platform or social media.

7] Approach industrial court to escalate the matter :- If a dispute has not been resolved within 45 days of moving the labour commissioner’s office, one can also move the industrial court of that region.

8] Be prepared to wait :- Court cases take time especially in the area of employer-employee conflicts due to a huge backlog of existing cases. Even if you have joined another company, a lot of time has to be invested in court hearings.

9] Keep a legal backup ready :- Though legal help is not necessary at the level of labour commissioner , it is advisable that employees take legal help, especially since companies come armed with their lawyers.

10] Out of court settlement could be easier :- Many employers choose to opt for out of court settlements since they are quicker and save the reputation of the company. If a company does give you this option, unless it has been a very unfair termination, it would be a good idea to go for this if the court case has been stretched for too long.

5 WAYS TO TERMINATE A CONTRACT

A contract is a legal document that binds atleast two parties to one another and requires them to meet certain obligations detailed in the contract. In some instances, contract termination can occur that will make the contract void of legal binding. Only the parties involved in the agreement may terminate a contract.

1] IMPOSSIBILITY OF PERFORMANCE :-

A contract typically requires one or more parties to do something which is called Performance.

Eg :- A company may hire and sign a contract to have a public speaker talk at a company event.

Once the public speaker fulfills his duties agreed upon in the contract, it is called performance. If for some reason it is impossible for the public speaker to fulfill his duties , it is called impossibility of performance or sometimes Frustration.

2] BREACH OF CONTRACT :-

When a contract is intentionally not honored by one party, it is called a Breach of Contract and is grounds for contract termination. A breach of contract may exist because one party failed to meet his obligations fully.

Eg :- If you purchase a product that did not arrive until a day after they agreed upon the delivery date that is an immaterial breach of contract.

However, if your orders did not come until two weeks after the delivery date and it affected your business, then that is material breach of contract.

TYPES OF TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT

2] DISCHARGE : The termination of employment of employees who are not workman are governed by the notice period in their employment contract and the Shops and Establishment Act ( ”S & E” ) of the state in which they work. Generally the State S & E’s provide for atleast one month’s notice of termination or pay in lieu of termination and in some instances, termination needs to be with cause and in some cases the employer needs to pay compensation for terminating the employee. The notice of dismissal under an employment contract should not be less favorable than what is prescribed under the law.

3] RETRENCHMENT : The ID Act sets out the steps to be undertaken for retrenchment. The term retrenchment has been defined to mean termination by the employer of employment of a worker, for any reason other than disciplinary grounds, with certain exceptions.

An employer who proposes to retrench a workman, who has been continously employed for more than one year , must give one month’s notice ( together with the reason for retrenchment) or pay in lieu of such notice to the workman.The employer must also inform the local labour authorities of the retrenchment within a stipulated time frame.

TYPES OF TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT

Termination of employment may take place due to misconduct, discharge or retrenchment.

  1. MISCONDUCT : Termination of employment can be for misconduct, for which the employer is required to conduct disciplinary proceedings . The procedure to terminate an employee in India, for conducting a disciplinary proceeding has been set out under law. It includes constituting and having a disciplinary panel, serving a show cause notice to the errant employee, and giving the employee a reasonable chance to put chance to put forth his defense. Proceedings have to be conducted in a fair manner, keeping in mind the principles of natural justice.

In some cases, the outcome of the disciplinary proceeding may justify dismissal without notice and any compensation. Under the law, the term misconduct provides a list of circumstances and events would amount to Misconduct. It is an inclusive list and hence the employers have the right to include in their company policies/ service rules, such other events as it may deem fit, which would in their line of business amount to misconduct.

Misconduct includes Wilful Insubordination or Disobedience; Theft , Fraud or Dishonesty; Wilful damage or Loss of employer’s property; Bribery; Habitual lateness or Absence; Striking unlawfully and Sexual harrasment.

The aforesaid procedure for termination will apply to all employees whether workman or non-workman.

TERMINATION BY LAW

As previously mentioned, any termination needs to comply with federal and state law because these laws supersede contract provisions. However, state law becomes the rule of the thumb for terminating an employee. State law itself is dependent on the area of operations.

☆ LABOUR LEGISLATION GOVERNING TERMINATION IN INDIAN STATES :

In the following section, we examine state laws for termination in several prominent investment destinations in India , including Delhi Union Territory, Maharashtra, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu.

☆ STATE LABOUR LAW IN DELHI UNION TERRITORY :

Under the Delhi Shops and Establishments Act of 1954, an employer cannot terminate an employee who has been with the company for more than three months without giving the employee atleast 30 days of notice or a salary in lieu of such notices. The employer need not give notice if misconduct is the cause for termination. However, the employee in such circumstances, should have an opportunity to reasonably explain the charge against them prior to termination.

☆ STATE LABOR LAW IN MAHARASHTRA :

Under the Maharashtra Shops and Establishments Act, an employer cannot terminate an employee who has been with the company for more than a year without giving the employee atleast 30 days of notice in writing. If an employee has been with the company more than 3 months but less than a year, the employer needs to give atleast 14 days of notice. The notice is not necessary if the employee is being terminated for misconduct.

SIX IMPORTANT COMPLIANCE RULES

1] The Industrial Disputes Act 1947, mandates a 30-90 day notice period when terminating ” workmen”. In the case of manufacturing units, plantations and mines with 100 or more workmen, “termination for convenience ” require government approval; in other sectors, it requires only government notification.

2] India’s Labor Laws cited the following reasons that justify termination for cause-wilful insubordinate or disobedience; theft fraud or Dishonesty , wilful damage to or loss of employer’s goods; partaking of bribes or any illegal gratification; absence without leave for more than 10 days, habitual late attendance, disorderly behaviour during working hours, or habitual negligence of work.

3] Employers that terminate for convenience must ensure that the last person to join the organization in the same role is first made redundant. It is an ideal practice that when such firms rehire for the same role, workmen who were terminated for convenience should be given the opportunity to rejoin the company.

4] In case of an employee being terminated in pregnant or seeking maternity leave, employers must balance their convenience against the risk associated with non-compliance with the provisions enshrined in the Maternity Benefit ( Ammendment ) Acr 2017.

5] Non-Compete agreements are not enforceable under Indian law, while non-solicitation clauses can be enforced only in limited ways.

6] The ‘work for hire’ principle applies under the Indian Copyright Regime; employees must thus provide formal assignments.

TERMINATION UNDER CONTRACT

In most cases, employment contracts are very specific about the process for terminationis by mutual agreement, and in particular cases where contractual agreement and in particular cases where contractual employment is set for a fixed period.

For instance, consultants with international organizations or interns at private organizations often have defined employment periods.

An employee is considered terminated at the conclusion of such a contract, unless a new contract is offered or the clauses in the initial contract are amended.

As in most countries, employees that are terminated by employers are often given one month notice or payments of one month of wages in Lieu thereof.

DUE PROCESS IN TERMINATING AN EMPLOYEE

Employers are exposed to a number of legal and reputational risks resulting from wrongful termination or not following due process. Employers should therefore plan to constuct contracts and human resources [HR] materials to ensure that senior management, HR personnel employees are fully apprised of their rights and responsibilites.

There is no standard process to terminate an employee in India. An employee may be terminated according to the individual labour contract signed between the employee and the employer termination.

Employers should be aware, however that labour laws supersede the provisions labour contracts – any termination policy or clause outlined within a contract should be checked against the law by a professional.

PREVENTION OF SEXUAL HARRASEMENT AT WORKPLACE :-

Sexual Harrasement of Women at Workplace [ Prevention, Prohibition and Readdressal ] Act, 2013 protects women at the workplace from sexual harrasement. The Indian Penal Code also provides a penalty upto three years with or without fine for sexual harrasement.

For organizations with ten or more employees, there has to be an Internal Complaint Committee constituted for the aid of victims of sexual harrasement. The law mandates that a Grievance readdressal policy and mechanisims be in place in such organizations which outlines what constitutes sexual harrassement , penalties, redressal mechanism , etc. The committee should also include a senior member , two other employees as member and non- governmental member.

RIGHT TO LEAVE

An employee has a right to paid public holidays and leaves such as Casual Leave, Sick Leave , Privilege Leave and other leaves. For every 240 days of work an employee is entitled to 12 days of Annual Leave. An Adult Worker may avail one earned leave every 20 days whereas it is 15 days for a young worker.

During notice period, an emploee can take leaves for emergencies, provided theemployment agreement does not bar it.